The data risk your security team worries about comes from external attackers. The data risk your CDO should worry about is sitting two floors below in the marketing department, running their own Tableau workbooks on a spreadsheet download from a system that hasn't been updated in six months.
Shadow IT and insider threats are the unglamorous data risks that never make the security conference keynotes, and are responsible for a significant proportion of real-world data incidents.
Shadow IT in data is any data processing happening outside your governed infrastructure. It looks like:
Every one of these scenarios creates data risk: GDPR non-compliance, data qualitydata qualityThe degree to which data is fit for purpose: accurate, complete, consistent, timely, valid and unique. Poor quality data undermines analytics, reporting and AI.View full definition → inconsistency (the "spreadsheet version" diverges from the authoritative source), security exposure (data in unauthorized systems), and governance breakdown (the CDO doesn't know what data is being used, by whom, for what purpose).
Shadow IT in data is almost always a symptom of legitimate frustration. People build their own solutions because the official infrastructure doesn't meet their needs. The CDO who responds with "stop doing that" without addressing the underlying need will fail. The CDO who makes the official infrastructure fast, accessible, and self-service will eliminate most shadow IT naturally.
Malicious insiders are employees or contractors who intentionally misuse their data access. They may steal customer data for financial gain, take confidential information to a competitor, or sabotage data systems. These are relatively rare but high-impact.
Negligent insiders, far more common, are employees who cause data incidents through carelessness rather than intent. The analyst who emails a customer list to a personal email address to work from home. The engineer who commits database credentials to a public GitHub repo. The customer service rep who accesses a celebrity's account out of curiosity.
Most data loss prevention (DLP) programs focus on malicious insiders. Most incidents are caused by negligent ones. The CDO's program should address both, with different approaches: technical controls for negligent actors (you can't email sensitive files to external addresses), behavioral monitoring for malicious ones.
CISA Cybersecurity Incident Response Playbook - Episode 1: An Overview
Knowledge check
1. According to the lesson, what is the most effective way for a CDO to reduce shadow IT in data?
2. What best characterizes the difference between a malicious and a negligent insider?
3. Why does the lesson argue that shadow IT and insider threats deserve more CDO attention than external attackers?
4. Select ALL of the following that are examples of shadow IT in data as described in the lesson.
Select all the correct answers.
5. Select ALL of the categories of data risk that shadow IT creates, according to the lesson.
Select all the correct answers.
In September 2022, Uber disclosed a major security breach. The attacker was an 18-year-old who didn't use sophisticated technical exploits. They used social engineering.
The attacker contacted an Uber employee via WhatsApp, claiming to be Uber IT security. They asked the employee to approve a multi-factor authentication (MFA) request. The employee, tired of repeated notifications (an "MFA fatigue" attack), eventually approved it. The attacker had full network access.
Once inside, the attacker found a PowerShell script on a network share. The script contained hard-coded credentials for Uber's privileged access management (PAM) system. With those credentials, they had access to virtually everything: AWS, Google Cloud, Slack, HubSpot, internal tools, and a security vulnerability database.
The data risk: the attacker found confidential files, internal security information, and potentially personal data of employees and drivers.
The CDO lessons:
1. Credential management: secrets (APIAPIApplication Programming Interface: a standardised interface that lets applications communicate and exchange data without knowing each other's internal workings.View full definition → keys, passwords, database credentials) must never be stored in scripts or code repositories. Use secrets managers (AWS Secrets Manager, HashiCorp Vault).
2. Least-privilege: once inside, the attacker had access to almost everything. Proper access segmentation limits the blast radius.
These actions are compiled in the role's Playbook.
3. MFA fatigue attacks are a real threat: implement number-matching MFA rather than simple push approval.
The CDO owns data risk, in partnership with the CISO. The CISO typically owns security infrastructure; the CDO owns data governancedata governanceData governance is the set of policies, roles, and processes that ensure data is accurate, secure, well-defined, and used responsibly across an organization.View full definition →, classification, and the policies that determine what's at risk.
A CDO data risk program includes: