+150 XP

Luxury · Why counterfeiting and grey markets are financial risks, not just legal ones

A €40 fake handbag sold on a street corner in Naples and a "like-new" Chanel bag resold by an unauthorized dealer in Dubai's Meena Bazaar have nothing in common legally. One is criminal counterfeiting. The other is perfectly legal resale of a genuine product. On a maison's income statement and balance sheet, though, they do the same damage. They cap how much the brand can charge, and they quietly erode brand value, the intangible asset that sits behind acquired-brand line items under IFRS and behind most valuation models.

This lesson treats both the way a finance function should: as margin leakage and pricing-power risk that can be measured and controlled.

Two different problems, one financial mechanism

Counterfeiting is the manufacture or sale of fake goods misrepresented as genuine. It is illegal everywhere and enforced under trademark law. In the EU that runs through registrations with the EU Intellectual Property Office, EUIPO. In the US it runs through the Lanham Act and US Customs and Border Protection (CBP).

Grey market resale is the unauthorized but legal sale of genuine goods. The goods are typically bought cheap in one market (a country with a favorable exchange rate or aggressive local discounting) and resold in another below the maison's official retail price. No trademark is infringed because the goods are real.

Both compress the same three financial levers:

  1. Gross margin. Grey market goods undercut the retail price. The maison either marks down or loses sales at full price.
  2. Pricing power. If consumers can reliably find "the same bag" cheaper elsewhere, the maison loses some of its ability to raise list prices. That ability matters a lot: in luxury financial models, price increases often outpace unit growth.
  3. Brand equity on the balance sheet. Groups like LVMH and Kering carry material goodwill and acquired brand value from past acquisitions (LVMH's annual reports show brands and other intangibles as a multi-billion-euro line). Over time, counterfeiting and uncontrolled resale are among the risk factors that can trigger impairment under IAS 36, the standard that requires a write-down when an asset's recoverable amount falls below its carrying value.

Sizing the problem: what we actually know

The most recent joint OECD/EUIPO study, "Mapping Global Trade in Fakes 2025", puts global trade in counterfeit goods at about $467 billion, or 2.3% of world imports. Those figures use 2021 customs seizure data. The previous edition (2021, using 2019 data) estimated $464 billion and 2.5%, so the headline number has stayed roughly flat. Treat both as modeled estimates, not current-year figures. Clothing, footwear, leather goods and watches remain among the most seized categories, and luxury brands are among the most frequently infringed.

Grey markets are harder to size. The goods are legal, so no customs seizure data captures them. Analysts infer scale from indirect signals instead:

  • price dispersion across regions for the same SKU (stock keeping unit, a unique product code);
  • volume mismatches between a maison's sell-in to authorized retailers and the resale listings observed on platforms like The RealReal, Vestiaire Collective or regional resellers.

A worked example: how leakage hits gross margin

Take a simplified handbag line:

  • Official retail price: €3,000
  • Maison's cost of goods sold (COGS): €600 (materials, labor, allocated overhead)
  • Standard gross margin: (3,000, 600) / 3,000 = 80%

Now suppose a grey market reseller in Dubai offers the same bag at €2,400. The reseller bought stock in a market with a weaker currency or deeper wholesale discounts.

Assume 10% of the maison's addressable demand shifts to that grey channel instead of buying at full retail. Two things happen:

  • The diverted units go to a channel where the maison earns nothing on the resale. It sold each unit once already, at wholesale, usually at a lower margin than direct retail.
  • The maison may also cut its own retail price to compete, say to €2,700. New margin: (2,700, 600) / 2,700 = 77.8%. That 2.2 point compression applies to every unit sold at the new price, across the full retail volume, and not only to the diverted 10%.

That is the mechanism. Grey market price anchoring lowers the ceiling for all sales.

Financial-control levers finance teams actually use

Finance and risk teams do not chase counterfeiters directly. That work belongs to legal teams and law enforcement. Finance controls the financial exposure, and it has three main levers.

1. Track-and-trace systems

Serialized identifiers tie each unit to a unique code, an RFID chip or a blockchain-based certificate. They let a maison verify authenticity and trace where a genuine product entered the resale chain. The named industry initiative is the Aura Blockchain Consortium, co-founded by LVMH, Prada Group and Richemont's Cartier. It now also issues digital product passports, which the EU's Ecodesign for Sustainable Products Regulation is set to require for some product categories.

For finance, track-and-trace data shows which authorized retailer or region is leaking stock into grey channels. Treasury and controlling teams can then quantify that diversion and price the risk into channel contracts.

2. Authorized reseller audits

Finance-led audits of wholesale partners check for over-ordering, unauthorized discounting and resale to non-approved third parties. Legal teams may join, but the core test is financial. It works like a channel-inventory reconciliation: sell-in volume to a partner should roughly match that partner's reported sell-through plus ending inventory. Large gaps signal diversion.

3. Resale capture

Some maisons now capture value from the secondary market instead of only fighting it. Concrete models include:

  • Vestiaire Collective's Brand Approved service, which buys back or takes in a brand's pre-owned items, as with Alexander McQueen;
  • in-house circular programs such as Mulberry's Exchange;
  • certified pre-owned watch programs run through authorized dealers, such as Rolex Certified Pre-Owned.

These turn a margin threat into a low-COGS revenue line. They also keep secondary-market pricing data inside the maison's own systems.

Not every house takes this route. Chanel has instead pursued resellers in court, including The RealReal and What Goes Around Comes Around, which shows the enforcement alternative.

Knowledge check

1. What is the key legal distinction between counterfeiting and grey market resale?

2. Why does the lesson argue that grey market resale, despite being legal, still matters to a maison's finance function?

3. A luxury group's financial model relies heavily on periodic price increases outpacing unit volume growth. How does widespread grey market availability of its products threaten this model?

MULTIPLE CHOICE

4. Select ALL correct answers about the financial mechanisms shared by counterfeiting and grey market resale.

Select all the correct answers.

MULTIPLE CHOICE

5. Select ALL correct answers about why this lesson frames counterfeiting and grey markets primarily as financial risks rather than purely legal issues.

Select all the correct answers.

Why this belongs in due diligence, not just brand protection

When you evaluate a luxury asset as an investor, lender or M&A analyst, treat counterfeiting and grey market exposure as real due-diligence items. These four checks are concrete:

  • Channel concentration. A maison that relies heavily on a few large wholesale accounts in markets with weak IP enforcement carries higher diversion risk. Parts of Southeast Asia and the Gulf resale hubs are typical examples.
  • Impairment history. Check whether the brand has taken goodwill or intangible impairment charges under IAS 36 or, for US filers, ASC 350. Recurring impairment can be a lagging signal of eroded pricing power.
  • Gross margin trend versus peers. Compare the maison with similar houses, for example Hermès against a mid-tier peer. If it loses margin points while volume holds steady, that is a classic sign of grey market leakage or discounting.
  • Resale program maturity. Find out whether the brand monetizes the secondary market or merely tolerates it. An official certified pre-owned program or resale partnership is a mitigating control.

🎬 [VIDEO: "How Luxury Brands Fight Counterfeiting" - youtube.com - search for OECD or EUIPO explainer content on the 2025 "Mapping Global Trade in Fakes" findings, useful for grounding the scale of the problem before assessing brand-level exposure]

Key Takeaways

  • Counterfeiting (illegal fakes) and grey market resale (legal but unauthorized) compress gross margin and pricing power through the same mechanism: price anchoring below official retail.
  • The latest OECD/EUIPO study (2025, using 2021 data) estimates counterfeit trade at about $467 billion, or 2.3% of world imports. It is a modeled estimate, and luxury categories remain heavily targeted.
  • In the worked example, a 10% demand diversion forces a retail price cut that compresses margin across the entire remaining volume, not only on the diverted units.
  • Finance controls include track-and-trace systems such as the Aura Blockchain Consortium, reseller audits that compare sell-in to sell-through, and resale programs that turn leakage into revenue.
  • In due diligence, check channel concentration, IAS 36/ASC 350 impairment history, gross margin trend versus peers, and resale program maturity.