+150 XP

Professional services · Privilege, confidentiality, and what you're legally forced to disclose

A partner at a mid-size law firm gets a call from a client under federal investigation. The same week, the firm's compliance officer flags a wire transfer pattern that looks like structuring, a classic money-laundering red flag. The lawyer wants to protect the client's confidences. Meanwhile, the client's bank has already filed a Suspicious Activity Report (SAR) on that same transaction, and the law forbids it from telling the client. Two professionals, two clients, two completely different disclosure rules governing the exact same facts. This is the seam where professional services work gets dangerous.

Three different shields, three different strengths

Professionals in law, accounting, and consulting often talk about "confidentiality" as one concept. It isn't. There are at least three distinct legal protections, and mixing them up is a common and costly mistake.

Attorney-client privilege is the strongest. It's a legal rule (rooted in common law and shaped in the US by cases like *Upjohn Co. v. United States*, 1981) that protects confidential communications between a lawyer and client made for the purpose of getting legal advice. It belongs to the client, not the lawyer, meaning only the client can waive it. It survives the client's death in most US jurisdictions.

Work-product doctrine is different and often confused with privilege. It protects materials prepared in anticipation of litigation (memos, interview notes, analysis) from discovery by an opposing party. It applies to lawyers and sometimes to accountants or consultants working under a lawyer's direction. It's weaker than privilege: courts can compel disclosure if the other side shows "substantial need" and can't get the material elsewhere.

Professional confidentiality obligations (accountant-client confidentiality, consultant NDAs, a medical-style duty of confidence) are the weakest. These are ethical or contractual duties, not evidentiary privileges. In the US there is no general federal accountant-client privilege. Section 7525 of the Internal Revenue Code creates a limited privilege for tax advice given by a CPA, but it doesn't apply in criminal tax matters, doesn't apply to audit work, and doesn't exist in most other contexts. If the IRS or SEC subpoenas an accountant's audit workpapers, "confidentiality" is not a valid shield.

This hierarchy matters because clients often assume anything they tell any professional is protected the way it would be with a lawyer. It isn't, and telling clients this upfront is itself part of managing risk.

Where mandatory disclosure overrides the shield

Even the strongest privilege has carve-outs, and several professions carry affirmative disclosure duties that exist specifically to override confidentiality.

The crime-fraud exception. Attorney-client privilege doesn't cover communications made to plan or commit an ongoing or future crime or fraud. A client asking "how do I structure this deal" is protected. A client asking "help me hide these assets from my creditors" likely isn't, once a court finds the exception applies.

SARs under the Bank Secrecy Act (BSA) and AML rules. Banks, broker-dealers, money services businesses, casinos and other covered financial institutions must file Suspicious Activity Reports with FinCEN (the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, part of the US Treasury) when they see transactions suggesting money laundering, fraud, or other illicit activity. The filer is legally barred from telling the subject that a report was filed, known as the "tipping off" prohibition. In the EU, the AML Directives require "obliged entities" (which explicitly include lawyers, notaries, and accountants in many circumstances) to file Suspicious Transaction Reports with national Financial Intelligence Units. That regime is being consolidated into a single, directly applicable EU AML Regulation (Regulation (EU) 2024/1624), which applies from July 2027, with a new EU Anti-Money Laundering Authority (AMLA) based in Frankfurt.

SOX and auditor reporting duties. The Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 (SOX), passed after the Enron and WorldCom collapses, tightened the rules for auditors of public companies. Under Section 10A of the Securities Exchange Act, an auditor who finds evidence of a likely illegal act must inform management and the audit committee. If the issue is material and the company fails to take appropriate remedial action, the auditor reports to the board, which has one business day to notify the SEC. If the board doesn't, the auditor must resign or send the report to the SEC itself. This legal duty overrides ordinary client confidentiality.

Mandatory reporting for other professionals. Depending on jurisdiction, this can extend to reporting suspected child abuse (many licensed professionals) or elder financial abuse. For lawyers, ABA Model Rule 1.6, adopted in some form in every US state, permits disclosure of confidential information to prevent reasonably certain death or substantial bodily harm, and some states make that disclosure mandatory.

The pattern: privilege protects the lawyer-client relationship almost absolutely, but nearly every other professional relationship has statutory disclosure duties layered on top of, or instead of, confidentiality.

The practical squeeze: real scenarios

Scenario 1: The auditor and the irregular revenue. An audit team discovers revenue recognition irregularities at a public client. Under Section 10A, they escalate to management and the audit committee first. If the board doesn't fix a material problem, the SEC hears about it one way or another, and the firm may also withdraw. Client confidentiality doesn't protect the client here.

Scenario 2: The law firm and the AML gatekeeper rules. In the EU and UK, lawyers handling certain transactions (real estate purchases, company formation, managing client money) are themselves obliged entities under AML law. They must perform customer due diligence and file suspicious transaction reports, even though the same lawyer's advice on litigation strategy would be fully privileged. The US still doesn't impose general gatekeeper AML obligations on lawyers, a long-standing gap flagged by the Financial Action Task Force. Two US developments shape the picture:

  • FinCEN's Residential Real Estate Rule, in effect since 1 March 2026, requires a report when residential property is transferred without bank financing to a legal entity or trust. The reporting person is often the settlement or closing agent, and in many states that is an attorney.
  • The Corporate Transparency Act's beneficial ownership reporting was sharply narrowed. A March 2025 FinCEN interim final rule exempted all US-formed companies and US persons, so only certain foreign companies registered to do business in the US still have to report.

Scenario 3: The consultant with no privilege at all. A management consultant hired to investigate a client's internal fraud has essentially no evidentiary privilege of their own. If litigation follows, the consultant's notes and interview memos can be subpoenaed unless the engagement was structured through outside counsel. The usual fix is a "Kovel arrangement," named for *United States v. Kovel* (1961) and originally developed for accountants working for law firms.

Knowledge check

1. A company's outside counsel interviews employees during an internal investigation and takes detailed notes for possible future litigation. What best describes the protection covering those notes?

2. Why did the bank in the scenario have no obligation to tell its customer that it filed a Suspicious Activity Report (SAR), while the lawyer faces a much higher bar before revealing client confidences?

3. A consultant works directly under a litigating attorney's direction to analyze data for an anticipated lawsuit. Which statement correctly captures how this affects legal protection of the consultant's analysis?

MULTIPLE CHOICE

4. Select ALL correct answers about attorney-client privilege.

Select all the correct answers.

MULTIPLE CHOICE

5. Select ALL correct answers about why treating 'confidentiality' as a single, uniform concept across law, accounting, and consulting is a mistake.

Select all the correct answers.

How firms actually manage the gap

The same few mechanisms show up repeatedly across professional services:

  • Kovel arrangements: hiring accountants or consultants through outside counsel so their work can fall under privilege or work-product protection, rather than standing alone with no shield.
  • Engagement letter carve-outs, which spell out in writing what is and isn't protected and which mandatory reporting obligations apply. Auditing standards already require auditors to communicate their responsibilities, and law and accounting firms increasingly do the same as standard practice.
  • Internal escalation protocols: multi-step review (engagement partner, general counsel, ethics or risk committee) before any external disclosure, both to comply with the law and to avoid disclosing more than the law requires.

For a grounded overview of how these obligations are framed for practicing accountants, the AICPA's Code of Professional Conduct is a useful primary source, and it's free to browse.

🎬 [VIDEO: "Attorney-Client Privilege Explained" - https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=attorney+client+privilege+explained+crime+fraud+exception - search for a short explainer covering privilege basics and the crime-fraud exception, useful for grounding the legal baseline before layering on AML and SOX duties]

Key Takeaways

  • Privilege, work-product doctrine, and professional confidentiality offer different strengths of protection. Attorney-client privilege is the strongest and belongs to the client; US accountants have only the narrow Section 7525 tax-advice privilege.
  • The crime-fraud exception strips privilege from communications made to plan future wrongdoing, and it is the pressure point in most privilege disputes.
  • Section 10A forces public-company auditors to escalate likely illegal acts internally and, if the board doesn't act on a material problem, to the SEC.
  • AML law forces SAR/STR filings with a strict no-tipping-off rule. In the EU and UK, lawyers and accountants acting as gatekeepers are covered, and the EU is moving to a single AML Regulation from July 2027. In the US, the 2026 residential real estate reporting rule can reach closing attorneys, while CTA beneficial ownership reporting now applies only to certain foreign companies.
  • Assuming "client confidentiality" covers everything is a common and expensive misunderstanding. Kovel arrangements, clear engagement letters, and escalation protocols are how firms manage the overlap.