Disclaimer

Educational content only. Not personalized investment advice. Historical data is indicative and should be verified before any decision. All investment carries a risk of capital loss.

Finance

Backscore: 40 trading and investment strategies scored on evidence

Backscore grades 20 trading strategies and 20 long-term investment strategies on one question: how solid is the evidence of a real edge after costs. It does not forecast returns. Below the catalogue, three tools let you practise: a market-scenario simulator, an allocation tool that projects a basket over your horizon, and a backtester on annual data from 1972 to 2024.

Free. Every lesson, article, podcast, tool and assessment, with no account needed to read.

The 40 strategies at a glance

Trading strategies
StrategyFamilyGradeScore
Momentum (3 to 12 months)MomentumA84/100
Post Earnings Drift (PEAD)Earnings anomalyB78/100
Opening Range Breakout (5 min)Intraday breakoutB76/100
Donchian / TurtleTrend followingB72/100
Carry trade (currencies)CarryB72/100
Low volatility anomalyFactorB72/100
52-week highMomentumB70/100
Internal Bar Strength (IBS)Mean reversionB68/100
RSI 2 (Connors)Mean reversionC60/100
Overnight edgeSession anomalyC60/100
Volatility risk premium (option selling)Premium sellingC58/100
Pairs trading / statistical arbitrageStatistical arbitrageC56/100
Sell in May (Halloween effect)SeasonalityC56/100
Bollinger Bands (mean reversion)Mean reversionC50/100
Moving average crossover 9/21Trend followingD44/100
Ichimoku systemTrend followingD42/100
MACD crossoverOscillatorD40/100
SupertrendTrend followingE32/100
Fibonacci retracementsChart levelsE30/100
Grid and martingaleLoss recoveryE26/100
Investment strategies
StrategyFamilyGradeScore
Broad index (S&P 500, total market)Passive indexA88/100
Global diversificationPassive indexA85/100
Three-fund portfolio (Bogleheads)Simple allocationA84/100
60/40 stocks and bondsBalanced allocationB78/100
Dollar-cost averaging (DCA)Entry methodB74/100
Quality factorFactorB74/100
Low volatility factorFactorB72/100
Value factorFactorB72/100
Momentum factorFactorB71/100
Real estate (rental, listed property companies)Real assetB70/100
Risk parity / All Weather (Dalio)All-weather allocationB68/100
Fundamental value investing (Graham, Buffett)Stock selectionB66/100
Quality bondsIncome and safetyB64/100
Tactical allocation with 200-day MA (Faber)Tactical allocationC62/100
Dividend growthIncomeC60/100
Sector rotationSector momentumC56/100
Gold and precious metalsHedgeC54/100
Active funds and stock pickingActive managementD44/100
Thematic investing (megatrends)ThemeD42/100
Leveraged ETFs held buy and holdLeverageE28/100

Trading

Trading strategies, scored on evidence

We score how reliable the evidence of a real edge net of fees is, not future profitability. Not investment advice.

A

Momentum (3 to 12 months)

Momentum

Buy what has already been rising for months, sell what is falling.

84/100
Assets
Stocks, indices, and beyond: currencies, commodities, bonds.
Horizon
Medium term, held 1 to 3 months.
Performance
Among the strongest premiums, several points a year gross in long-short.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence5/5
  • Out of sample5/5
  • Survives costs3/5
  • Robustness4/5
  • Honesty4/5

In plain words: The most replicated anomaly, over decades and across many markets.

Caveat: Suffers brutal crashes and gets eroded by crowding and costs.

Reference: Jegadeesh & Titman (1993). (link to come)

How it works
  1. Rank a universe by performance over 3 to 12 months.
  2. Buy the top, avoid the bottom.
  3. Rebalance every month.
  4. Risk: crashes when trends reverse.
B

Post Earnings Drift (PEAD)

Earnings anomaly

After an earnings surprise, the price drifts in the direction of the surprise.

78/100
Assets
Individual stocks, around earnings releases.
Horizon
A few weeks to a few months.
Performance
Abnormal return of 2.6 to 9.37% per year, weaker recently.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence5/5
  • Out of sample4/5
  • Survives costs3/5
  • Robustness4/5
  • Honesty4/5

In plain words: One of the best documented anomalies, since Ball and Brown (1968).

Caveat: Has weakened recently; requires earnings surprise data.

Abnormal return of 2.6 to 9.37% per year. See the source

How it works
  1. Measure the earnings surprise.
  2. Buy strong positive surprises.
  3. Hold a few weeks.
  4. The market underreacts, then catches up.
B

Opening Range Breakout (5 min)

Intraday breakout

Mark the high and low of the first minutes, follow the breakout.

76/100
Assets
The day's most active US stocks, indices via futures.
Horizon
Pure intraday.
Performance
Up to +1484% on TQQQ with 3x leverage in the study, far more modest without leverage.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence5/5
  • Out of sample3/5
  • Survives costs4/5
  • Robustness3/5
  • Honesty4/5

In plain words: A real study on a large sample, costs included.

Caveat: The headline return comes from 3x leverage.

Zarattini & Aziz, SSRN. See the source

How it works
  1. Note the high and low of the first 5 minutes.
  2. Buy above, sell below the box, stop on the other side.
  3. Close before the end of the session.
  4. Only on the day's most active stocks.
B

Donchian / Turtle

Trend following

Buy at the high of the last N days, follow the trend.

72/100
Assets
Diversified basket of futures.
Horizon
A few days to several weeks.
Performance
High single-digit annualized return, very uneven.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence4/5
  • Out of sample4/5
  • Survives costs3/5
  • Robustness4/5
  • Honesty3/5

In plain words: Robust on a diversified basket of futures, validated by CTAs.

Caveat: Works on a portfolio, not a single asset; recent years have been dull.

Source to be added. (link to come)

How it works
  1. Plot the 20-day high and low.
  2. Buy on a break of the high, cut losses fast.
  3. On a diversified basket.
  4. A few big trends make the result.
B

Carry trade (currencies)

Carry

Borrow a low-rate currency to invest in a high-rate currency.

72/100
Assets
Currency pairs with a wide interest rate differential.
Horizon
Medium to long term.
Performance
Up to 12% annualized, but a third of it pays for crash risk.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence5/5
  • Out of sample4/5
  • Survives costs3/5
  • Robustness3/5
  • Honesty4/5

In plain words: A documented premium, up to 12% annualized historically.

Caveat: Crash risk: brutal losses in a crisis.

Negative skewness, an inherent risk (Brunnermeier). See the source

How it works
  1. Rank currencies by interest rate.
  2. Buy the high rates, sell the low ones.
  3. Collect the spread while calm lasts.
  4. In a crisis, everything falls together.
B

Low volatility anomaly

Factor

The least volatile stocks have historically returned more.

72/100
Assets
Low-volatility stocks, low vol ETFs.
Horizon
Long term.
Performance
The least volatile decile beat the most volatile by about 5 points a year.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence5/5
  • Out of sample5/5
  • Survives costs4/5
  • Robustness4/5
  • Honesty4/5

In plain words: Documented since 1972, confirmed in many markets.

Caveat: Rather a long-term play, and the trade has become crowded.

Black, Jensen & Scholes (1972), Frazzini & Pedersen. See the source

How it works
  1. Rank by volatility.
  2. Buy the least volatile.
  3. Hold for a long time.
  4. Leverage constraints explain the effect.
B

52-week high

Momentum

Buy stocks close to their one-year high.

70/100
Assets
Stocks and indices.
Horizon
Medium term.
Performance
About 0.28% per month, positive in 18 of the 20 markets.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence5/5
  • Out of sample4/5
  • Survives costs3/5
  • Robustness4/5
  • Honesty3/5

In plain words: Profitable in 18 of the 20 markets studied.

Caveat: A cousin of momentum: same reversal risks.

George & Hwang (2004), ~0.28% per month. See the source

How it works
  1. Spot the stocks close to their 52-week high.
  2. Buy that basket.
  3. Rebalance every month.
  4. A simple variant of momentum.
B

Internal Bar Strength (IBS)

Mean reversion

Buy when the close sits at the bottom of the day's range.

68/100
Assets
Index ETFs.
Horizon
Very short term, 1 to 2 days.
Performance
A real daily edge, but small per trade.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence4/5
  • Out of sample3/5
  • Survives costs3/5
  • Robustness4/5
  • Honesty3/5

In plain words: A simple, documented edge on index ETFs.

Caveat: Mostly on indices; mean reversion has weakened.

Source to be added. (link to come)

How it works
  1. Compute where the close sits in the day's range.
  2. Buy at the close when it is very low.
  3. Sell on the return toward the mean.
  4. Mostly on index ETFs.
C

RSI 2 (Connors)

Mean reversion

Buy an index at extreme oversold levels, sell on the return toward the mean.

60/100
Assets
Equity indices, in an underlying bull market.
Horizon
Short term, a few days.
Performance
High win rate (65 to 75%) but a small average gain.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence4/5
  • Out of sample2/5
  • Survives costs3/5
  • Robustness3/5
  • Honesty3/5

In plain words: Historically very strong on equity indices.

Caveat: The edge eroded after 2010.

Connors & Alvarez. See the source

How it works
  1. Index above its 200-day MA.
  2. Buy when RSI 2 drops very low.
  3. Sell above a short moving average.
  4. Effect weakened since 2010.
C

Overnight edge

Session anomaly

Hold only overnight: buy at the close, sell at the open.

60/100
Assets
US indices and large caps.
Horizon
One night.
Performance
Most of the long-run rise in indices happened outside trading hours.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence4/5
  • Out of sample4/5
  • Survives costs2/5
  • Robustness3/5
  • Honesty2/5

In plain words: An established fact that gains concentrate outside trading hours.

Caveat: Net of costs, the edge melts away for a retail investor.

Source to be added. (link to come)

How it works
  1. Buy at the close.
  2. Sell at the open.
  3. You only hold overnight.
  4. Daily costs eat the edge.
C

Volatility risk premium (option selling)

Premium selling

Sell options to collect the premium.

58/100
Assets
Index options.
Horizon
Short to medium term.
Performance
High Sharpe ratio, but severe losses in 2008 and February 2018.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence4/5
  • Out of sample4/5
  • Survives costs3/5
  • Robustness2/5
  • Honesty2/5

In plain words: A real premium, with a historically high Sharpe ratio.

Caveat: Tail risk: violent losses in crashes.

Quantpedia, high tail risk. See the source

How it works
  1. Sell out-of-the-money options.
  2. Collect the premium while it is calm.
  3. Manage risk strictly.
  4. Picking up pennies in front of a steamroller.
C

Pairs trading / statistical arbitrage

Statistical arbitrage

Two related assets drift apart; you bet on them converging again.

56/100
Assets
Pairs of highly correlated assets.
Horizon
A few days to a few weeks.
Performance
About 11% annualized over 1962 to 2002, then decline.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence4/5
  • Out of sample3/5
  • Survives costs2/5
  • Robustness3/5
  • Honesty2/5

In plain words: Supported by research from the 1990s and 2000s.

Caveat: Profitability has declined sharply with competition.

Gatev, Goetzmann & Rouwenhorst. (link to come)

How it works
  1. Find two highly correlated assets.
  2. Watch the spread.
  3. Buy the laggard, sell the leader.
  4. Unwind when things return to normal.
C

Sell in May (Halloween effect)

Seasonality

Be invested from November to April, scale back from May to October.

56/100
Assets
Equity indices.
Horizon
Seasonal.
Performance
Winter beats summer in 36 of 37 countries, confirmed over 323 years.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence4/5
  • Out of sample4/5
  • Survives costs3/5
  • Robustness3/5
  • Honesty2/5

In plain words: A robust effect, winter beats summer in 36 of 37 countries.

Caveat: A crude tool, suspected of data mining.

Bouman & Jacobsen (2002). See the source

How it works
  1. Invested from November to April.
  2. Scaled back from May to October.
  3. Repeat every year.
  4. Robust but crude.
C

Bollinger Bands (mean reversion)

Mean reversion

Buy when price touches the lower band, bet on the return.

50/100
Assets
Index ETFs in a bull market.
Horizon
Short term.
Performance
Rebound after two closes below the lower band, but it fades in a downturn.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence3/5
  • Out of sample3/5
  • Survives costs2/5
  • Robustness2/5
  • Honesty2/5

In plain words: A real rebound on index ETFs in a bull market.

Caveat: Depends on the regime, fails in a bear market.

QuantifiedStrategies. See the source

How it works
  1. Plot the Bollinger Bands.
  2. Buy at the lower band in an uptrend.
  3. Sell at the middle.
  4. Add a confirmation filter.
D

Moving average crossover 9/21

Trend following

Buy on the bullish crossover, sell on the opposite crossover.

44/100
Assets
Tested everywhere, robust nowhere in raw form.
Horizon
Variable.
Performance
Zero or negative expectancy in raw form.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence4/5
  • Out of sample2/5
  • Survives costs1/5
  • Robustness2/5
  • Honesty2/5

In plain words: The raw version loses in most conditions.

Caveat: Whipsaws in a trendless market.

Independent SPY/ES backtests. See the source

How it works
  1. Two averages, a fast 9 and a slow 21.
  2. Buy on the crossover, sell on the opposite crossover.
  3. Whipsaws in a trendless market.
  4. Only viable with a trend filter.
D

Ichimoku system

Trend following

A set of lines and a cloud for trend, signals and levels.

42/100
Assets
Indices, forex, stocks.
Horizon
Variable.
Performance
One test shows a 54.7% win rate, another 10% over 15024 trades.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence3/5
  • Out of sample2/5
  • Survives costs2/5
  • Robustness2/5
  • Honesty2/5

In plain words: Readable and visually complete.

Caveat: Backtests contradict each other depending on the implementation.

One study of 15024 trades shows a 10% win rate. See the source

How it works
  1. Display tenkan, kijun and the cloud.
  2. Buy above the cloud.
  3. Results range from decent to disastrous depending on the implementation.
D

MACD crossover

Oscillator

Crossover of a moving-average oscillator to spot a change in momentum.

40/100
Assets
All markets, with no edge of its own.
Horizon
Variable.
Performance
No robust positive expectancy on its own.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence3/5
  • Out of sample2/5
  • Survives costs1/5
  • Robustness2/5
  • Honesty2/5

In plain words: A lagging indicator, no robust edge on its own.

Caveat: Many false signals.

Source to be added. (link to come)

How it works
  1. Buy when the signal line is crossed upward.
  2. The signal comes late.
  3. Multiplies false starts in a choppy market.
  4. A reading tool, not a system.
E

Supertrend

Trend following

A volatility-based line that tells you to buy or sell.

32/100
Assets
Indices, forex, crypto.
Horizon
Intraday to swing.
Performance
No evidence of positive expectancy outside cherry-picked examples.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence2/5
  • Out of sample1/5
  • Survives costs2/5
  • Robustness2/5
  • Honesty1/5

In plain words: Very popular on video, almost no solid evidence.

Caveat: Highly prone to overfitting.

Source to be added. (link to come)

How it works
  1. A line set at a distance from price, computed from the ATR.
  2. It flips to say buy or sell.
  3. The distance depends on settings optimized after the fact.
  4. Fragile and misleading.
E

Fibonacci retracements

Chart levels

Draw levels at 38, 50 and 62% of a move.

30/100
Assets
All markets.
Horizon
Variable.
Performance
No statistical edge: does as well as random levels.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence2/5
  • Out of sample1/5
  • Survives costs2/5
  • Robustness2/5
  • Honesty1/5

In plain words: Popular and easy to draw.

Caveat: Does not beat randomly chosen levels.

Empirical study, Fibonacci levels vs random levels. See the source

How it works
  1. Draw the 38, 50, 62% levels.
  2. Wait for a reaction.
  3. Nothing says price respects them.
  4. At best a self-fulfilling prophecy.
E

Grid and martingale

Loss recovery

Stack positions, and double the stake after each loss.

26/100
Assets
Forex and crypto, via bots.
Horizon
Short term.
Performance
Many small gains, then a catastrophic loss.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence2/5
  • Out of sample1/5
  • Survives costs2/5
  • Robustness1/5
  • Honesty1/5

In plain words: An illusion of steadiness, many small gains.

Caveat: Risk of ruin: one losing streak wipes out the account.

Capital.com, Myfxbook. See the source

How it works
  1. The grid places orders at intervals.
  2. The martingale doubles after each loss.
  3. A sustained trend makes exposure explode.
  4. Stay away.

Investing

Long-term investment strategies

We score how solid the evidence is that an approach builds wealth, and say in concrete terms what it returned against its benchmark.

A

Broad index (S&P 500, total market)

Passive index

Buy and hold a broad, low-cost index fund.

88/100
Profile
Portfolio core for any investor.
Horizon
Long term, 10 years or more.
Return
About 7 to 10% a year in nominal terms for US equities.
In practice
This is the benchmark: about 10% a year for the S&P 500 over the very long term.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence5/5
  • Long-term robustness5/5
  • Low fees5/5
  • Controlled risk3/5
  • Easy to stick with5/5

In plain words: Over 15 years, 85 to 90% of active funds are beaten.

Caveat: 100% equities, large drops (40 to 50%).

SPIVA, S&P Dow Jones. See the source

How to apply it
  1. One broad, low-cost index ETF.
  2. Invest regularly.
  3. Never sell in a panic.
  4. Reinvest the dividends.
A

Global diversification

Passive index

Hold all of the world's equities through a single ETF.

85/100
Profile
Portfolio core, broad exposure.
Horizon
Long term.
Return
About 6 to 8% a year for global equities.
In practice
A little below the S&P 500 over the 2010s, but more diversified.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence5/5
  • Long-term robustness5/5
  • Low fees5/5
  • Controlled risk4/5
  • Easy to stick with5/5

In plain words: Captures global growth, dilutes country risk.

Caveat: Still 100% equities, tracks the world average.

Diversification and indexing (SPIVA). See the source

How to apply it
  1. One low-cost global equity ETF.
  2. Invest regularly.
  3. Let it run.
  4. Do not chase the fashionable country.
A

Three-fund portfolio (Bogleheads)

Simple allocation

Three ETFs: domestic equities, international equities, bonds.

84/100
Profile
Self-directed investor.
Horizon
Long term.
Return
Weighted average of equities and bonds.
In practice
Below 100% S&P 500 in rising markets, better in falling ones thanks to bonds.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence5/5
  • Long-term robustness5/5
  • Low fees5/5
  • Controlled risk4/5
  • Easy to stick with4/5

In plain words: Diversified, easy to read and almost free.

Caveat: Needs a little rebalancing.

Bogle philosophy (SPIVA). See the source

How to apply it
  1. Domestic equities, international equities, bonds.
  2. Bond weight set by your risk level.
  3. Rebalance once a year.
  4. Keep fees as low as possible.
B

60/40 stocks and bonds

Balanced allocation

60% equities, 40% bonds, rebalanced every year.

78/100
Profile
Growth with gentler drops.
Horizon
Long term.
Return
About 7 to 8% a year, smaller drops.
In practice
About 7 to 8% a year against 10% for the S&P 500, but much gentler drops (except 2022).
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence4/5
  • Long-term robustness4/5
  • Low fees4/5
  • Controlled risk4/5
  • Easy to stick with4/5

In plain words: Bonds soften the drops of equities.

Caveat: In 2022, both fell together.

Classic balanced allocation. (link to come)

How to apply it
  1. 60% equities, 40% bonds.
  2. Rebalance every year.
  3. Adjust with age.
  4. Do not deviate under stress.
B

Dollar-cost averaging (DCA)

Entry method

Invest a fixed amount at regular intervals.

74/100
Profile
Saver investing from salary.
Horizon
Long term, through regular payments.
Return
Tracks the market, slightly below a lump sum.
In practice
About 2.4% a year less than investing everything at once, in the same market.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence4/5
  • Long-term robustness4/5
  • Low fees4/5
  • Controlled risk4/5
  • Easy to stick with5/5

In plain words: Natural for savings, smooths the entry price.

Caveat: Lump sum beats DCA 2 times out of 3.

Vanguard. See the source

How to apply it
  1. Fixed amount, regular frequency.
  2. Invest automatically.
  3. Do not stop during a fall.
  4. A large sum is better invested all at once.
B

Quality factor

Factor

Overweight profitable companies with little debt.

74/100
Profile
Defensive factor building block.
Horizon
Long term.
Return
Premium of 3 to 4.7% a year above the market.
In practice
About +3 to 4.7% a year against the market.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence5/5
  • Long-term robustness4/5
  • Low fees4/5
  • Controlled risk4/5
  • Easy to stick with3/5

In plain words: Premium of 3 to 4.7% a year, with less volatility.

Caveat: Goes through lean periods.

Quality minus junk (QMJ). See the source

How to apply it
  1. A quality ETF with reasonable fees.
  2. As a complement to an index core.
  3. Hold for the long term.
  4. Do not stack too many factors.
B

Low volatility factor

Factor

Favor the least volatile stocks.

72/100
Profile
Equities with gentler drops.
Horizon
Long term.
Return
Outperformance of 2 to 6% a year, with less risk.
In practice
About +2 to 6% a year against the market, with lower volatility.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence5/5
  • Long-term robustness4/5
  • Low fees4/5
  • Controlled risk4/5
  • Easy to stick with3/5

In plain words: Premium of 2 to 6% with less risk.

Caveat: Underperforms in euphoric markets.

Low volatility anomaly. See the source

How to apply it
  1. A low volatility ETF.
  2. Defensive part of the equity sleeve.
  3. Accept underperforming in euphoric phases.
  4. Check the fees.
B

Value factor

Factor

Overweight undervalued stocks.

72/100
Profile
Patient investor.
Horizon
Long term.
Return
Premium of 2 to 4% a year, long dry spells.
In practice
About +2 to 4% a year over a very long period, but below the S&P 500 from 2010 to 2020.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence5/5
  • Long-term robustness3/5
  • Low fees4/5
  • Controlled risk3/5
  • Easy to stick with3/5

In plain words: Premium of 2 to 4% a year over a very long period.

Caveat: A lean decade in the 2010s.

Value factor (Fama-French). See the source

How to apply it
  1. A low-cost value ETF.
  2. Combine with an index core.
  3. Accept long periods of underperformance.
  4. Very long horizon.
B

Momentum factor

Factor

Overweight stocks that have been rising for months.

71/100
Profile
Comfortable with volatility.
Horizon
Medium to long term.
Return
Premium of 3 to 5% a year, periodic crashes.
In practice
About +3 to 5% a year against the market, at the cost of crashes.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence5/5
  • Long-term robustness3/5
  • Low fees3/5
  • Controlled risk3/5
  • Easy to stick with3/5

In plain words: Premium of 3 to 5%, one of the most persistent effects.

Caveat: Sharp crashes, turnover costs.

Momentum (Jegadeesh & Titman, AQR). See the source

How to apply it
  1. A momentum ETF.
  2. As a satellite, not the core.
  3. Accept reversals.
  4. Watch the fees.
B

Real estate (rental, listed property companies)

Real asset

Rental property or listed property companies, income and capital gains.

70/100
Profile
Ready to manage a property, or through listed property companies.
Horizon
Very long term.
Return
Total return comparable to equities, less volatile.
In practice
Comparable to the S&P 500 according to studies, less volatile, but often lower net of costs.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence4/5
  • Long-term robustness4/5
  • Low fees2/5
  • Controlled risk3/5
  • Easy to stick with2/5

In plain words: A real asset that produces income, weakly correlated with equities.

Caveat: Leverage, illiquidity, costs and management.

Long-term return studies. (link to come)

How to apply it
  1. For listed exposure, low-cost property companies.
  2. For direct ownership, include every cost.
  3. Separate gross and net yield.
  4. Diversify.
B

Risk parity / All Weather (Dalio)

All-weather allocation

Balance risk across equities, bonds, gold and commodities.

68/100
Profile
Values consistency.
Horizon
Long term.
Return
Good risk-adjusted returns, gentler drops.
In practice
In raw return, below 100% equities in rising markets, but better risk-adjusted.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence4/5
  • Long-term robustness3/5
  • Low fees3/5
  • Controlled risk5/5
  • Easy to stick with3/5

In plain words: Better risk-adjusted return in every environment.

Caveat: Depends on bonds and leverage; 2022 was hard.

Ray Dalio's All Weather. (link to come)

How to apply it
  1. Spread the risk, not the capital.
  2. Long bonds, gold, commodities.
  3. Rebalance.
  4. Understand leverage before using it.
B

Fundamental value investing (Graham, Buffett)

Stock selection

Buy quality companies at a reasonable price, hold them for a long time.

66/100
Profile
Understand, analyze, hold for years.
Horizon
Very long term.
Return
Sharpe of about 0.79 over decades.
In practice
Berkshire beat the S&P 500 over 50 years, thanks to quality, low beta and leverage.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence4/5
  • Long-term robustness4/5
  • Low fees3/5
  • Controlled risk3/5
  • Easy to stick with2/5

In plain words: Buffett's alpha: quality, low beta, leverage of 1.7.

Caveat: Rare talent, most stock pickers fail.

Buffett's Alpha (AQR). See the source

How to apply it
  1. Quality companies, not expensive.
  2. Think like an owner.
  3. Hold for a very long time.
  4. The edge comes from factors and financing.
B

Quality bonds

Income and safety

Safe bonds with staggered maturities, for income and stability.

64/100
Profile
Cushion the volatility of equities.
Horizon
Medium to long term.
Return
Modest but steady return.
In practice
Well below equities, a few % a year; a shock absorber.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence4/5
  • Long-term robustness4/5
  • Low fees4/5
  • Controlled risk4/5
  • Easy to stick with4/5

In plain words: Stabilizes, produces income, protects in a recession.

Caveat: Low real return, sensitive to rates (2022).

The role of bonds. (link to come)

How to apply it
  1. Quality bonds.
  2. Stagger the maturities.
  3. A shock absorber, not an engine.
  4. A bond ETF for simplicity.
C

Tactical allocation with 200-day MA (Faber)

Tactical allocation

Invested above the 10-month moving average, in cash otherwise.

62/100
Profile
Limit the big drops.
Horizon
Long term.
Return
Return close to equities, volatility of bonds.
In practice
Drawdown cut from 46% to under 10%; below the S&P 500 in a continuous bull market.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence4/5
  • Long-term robustness3/5
  • Low fees3/5
  • Controlled risk4/5
  • Easy to stick with3/5

In plain words: Drawdown cut from about 46% to under 10%.

Caveat: Underperforms in a sustained bull market, costs and taxes.

Faber, Tactical Asset Allocation. See the source

How to apply it
  1. At each month end, check against the 10-month average.
  2. Above: invested; below: cash.
  3. No exceptions.
  4. Account for costs and taxes.
C

Dividend growth

Income

Companies that raise their dividend regularly.

60/100
Profile
Visible, growing income.
Horizon
Long term.
Return
Total return close to the market.
In practice
Total return close to the S&P 500, with no magic premium.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence3/5
  • Long-term robustness4/5
  • Low fees3/5
  • Controlled risk4/5
  • Easy to stick with3/5

In plain words: Quality tilt and growing income.

Caveat: No magic; chasing high yield is a trap.

Part of the effect comes from the quality factor. (link to come)

How to apply it
  1. Sustainable, growing dividends.
  2. Think in total return.
  3. Reinvest.
  4. Diversify.
C

Sector rotation

Sector momentum

Overweight sectors with relative strength.

56/100
Profile
Active investor.
Horizon
Medium term.
Return
Mixed results.
In practice
Often below the S&P 500 once fees are paid.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence3/5
  • Long-term robustness3/5
  • Low fees3/5
  • Controlled risk3/5
  • Easy to stick with2/5

In plain words: A form of sector momentum.

Caveat: Hard for an individual, costs and false rotations.

Momentum and relative strength. See the source

How to apply it
  1. Measure the relative strength of sectors.
  2. Overweight the leaders.
  3. Limit round trips.
  4. Keep a diversified base.
C

Gold and precious metals

Hedge

A share of gold as a hedge and diversifier.

54/100
Profile
Insurance against shocks.
Horizon
Long term.
Return
Real return close to zero, a cushion in crises.
In practice
Far below the S&P 500 over the long term, but uncorrelated in crises.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence3/5
  • Long-term robustness3/5
  • Low fees4/5
  • Controlled risk4/5
  • Easy to stick with4/5

In plain words: A useful diversifier in crises and inflation.

Caveat: Real return close to zero.

Gold as a diversifier. (link to come)

How to apply it
  1. 5 to 10% of the portfolio.
  2. Insurance, not an engine.
  3. An ETF backed by physical gold.
  4. Rebalance.
D

Active funds and stock picking

Active management

An active manager, or your own stock picks, to beat the index.

44/100
Profile
Tries to beat the market.
Horizon
Variable.
Return
On average, below the index after fees.
In practice
About 1 to 2% a year below the index after fees; 85 to 90% beaten over 15 years.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence2/5
  • Long-term robustness2/5
  • Low fees2/5
  • Controlled risk3/5
  • Easy to stick with3/5

In plain words: A few managers really manage it.

Caveat: 85 to 90% of funds beaten over 15 years.

SPIVA. See the source

How to apply it
  1. Low fees and a real process.
  2. Compare with the index, fees included.
  3. Be wary of past performance.
  4. Index investing remains the safer bet.
D

Thematic investing (megatrends)

Theme

Bet on the big future themes through specialized ETFs.

42/100
Profile
Small satellite sleeve.
Horizon
Long term, often bought at the wrong time.
Return
Very dispersed, on average below the market after launch.
In practice
On average -6% a year against the market in the first 5 years. ARKK: -80% after February 2021, ~13.8% a year since 2014 against 13.6% for the S&P 500, but three times as volatile.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.

The main themes

  • Artificial intelligence: The hottest, high valuations.
  • Semiconductors: Cyclical, very volatile, the core of AI.
  • Clean energy: Long-term trend, sensitive to rates and subsidies.
  • Water: Defensive, slow and steady growth.
  • Robotics: Productivity and demographics.
  • Cybersecurity: Structurally growing spending.
  • Genomics: Huge but binary potential.
  • Aging and health: Demographic megatrend.
  • Defense: Driven by geopolitics.
  • Transition metals: Copper, lithium, grids.
  • Evidence2/5
  • Long-term robustness2/5
  • Low fees2/5
  • Controlled risk2/5
  • Easy to stick with3/5

In plain words: Megatrends are real.

Caveat: Specialized ETFs lose about 6% a year for 5 years after launch.

Ben-David et al., Competition for Attention in the ETF Space. See the source

How to apply it
  1. A theme whose driver you understand.
  2. A small satellite sleeve, never the core.
  3. Avoid buying after the media frenzy.
  4. A broad ETF rather than a star stock.
E

Leveraged ETFs held buy and hold

Leverage

Hold a 2x or 3x leveraged ETF over the long term.

28/100
Profile
At best, very short-term use by experienced traders.
Horizon
Designed for a single day.
Return
Drifts away from its multiple because of daily compounding.
In practice
Can end far below the underlying in a choppy market.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
  • Evidence2/5
  • Long-term robustness1/5
  • Low fees2/5
  • Controlled risk1/5
  • Easy to stick with2/5

In plain words: Multiplies daily gains in a steady rise.

Caveat: Volatility decay, high fees, risk of ruin.

Leveraged ETF decay. See the source

How to apply it
  1. The multiple is daily only.
  2. Volatility erodes the value.
  3. Not a core holding.
  4. Extreme risk.

Method

How the scores work

Each strategy gets a score out of 100 and a grade from A to E. The score measures the reliability of the evidence, not the performance to come. A strategy can have made money in the past and still score low if that result does not survive costs, does not repeat out of sample or depends on a setting chosen after the fact.

A and B: solid evidenceC: average evidence, conditional on the regime or erodedD and E: weak or no evidence

The five trading criteria

Evidence
How much published research and data support the effect.
Out of sample
Whether the effect held after publication, and on markets and periods it was not designed on.
Survives costs
Whether an edge is left once fees, spreads and slippage are paid.
Robustness
Whether it works across markets and settings, or only with one tuned configuration.
Honesty
Whether the way it is usually sold matches what the data shows.

The five investment criteria

Evidence
How much research and long data series support the approach.
Long-term robustness
Whether it held over decades and across market regimes.
Low fees
What it costs to hold, year after year.
Controlled risk
How deep and how long the drops can be.
Easy to stick with
Whether an ordinary investor can keep to it through a crash without selling.

Each criterion is rated from 0 to 5. Figures quoted in the cards are historical and gross unless stated otherwise. Where a source link is missing, the reference is named and the link will be added.

Simulator

Read the market, pick your strategy, spot the trap

Choose your ground, trading or investing, and train on 29 market situations. The answer shows, with sources, the right choice and the traps.

Score 0 / 0 · streak 0 · 29 situations
E-mini S&P 5001 candle = 5 minutes20 candles
99100100101pricetimehighlowrange

The last 20 candles swing inside a horizontal channel, with no clear direction.

RSI 250, neutral
Trend (ADX)14, very weak
Positionbetween MA50 and MA200
Volatilityaverage

Which approach fits best?

Allocation

Allocation tool: project your wealth

Enter your capital, monthly contribution, horizon and profile. The tool projects your portfolio and compares it with 100% S&P 500 and with real estate. Historical assumptions, not a guarantee.

Build your basket in percent, normalized automatically

1. Core allocationthe first decision
60%

Your stock allocation: the engine of return and of risk. Its mix is set in step 2. Historically 7 to 10% a year, with drops of 40 to 50%.

25%

Lending to governments and large companies: income and stability, a cushion for stocks. A few % a year, low volatility outside rate shocks.

10%

A real asset: rental income and capital gains, a diversifier for stocks. Total return close to stocks over the very long run, less volatile.

5%

A safe-haven metal, useful in crises and inflation. Real return close to zero, but uncorrelated in a crisis.

0%

Liquidity: safety and availability. Low return, eaten by inflation over time.

2. How to invest your stock allocation split of the Stocks share

70%

The default passive choice, the whole planet. About 7% a year, volatility 15%.

30%

The 500 largest US companies, more concentrated. About 8% a year, volatility 16%.

Basket: expected return 5.9% a year, volatility 10%. Stocks 60%, of which 0% in satellite themes.
cautiousbalancedaggressive

The range covers about two thirds of scenarios. Combining several stock factors barely diversifies, they move together; mixing stocks, bonds, gold and real estate does.

€ 100,000total paid in
€ 247,438basket, median scenario
€ 177,012 to € 353,103likely range
€ 358,710100% S&P 500
€ 252,548real estate
0k90k179k269k359kYour basket (range)100% S&P 500Real estate

Each building block shows its indicative expected return and volatility. The range covers about two thirds of scenarios, at plus or minus one standard deviation, taking the basket's diversification into account. Sector themes are high risk and underperform on average once the hype fades. Approximate, historical returns, never a guarantee. This is not investment advice.

Backtester 1972-2024

Historical backtester: compare the past

Pick up to three strategies and see how a sum invested would have grown since 1972, their annualized return and their worst drawdown. Indicative annual data, to be checked.

Build my custom mix, then pick "My custom mix" in one of the three lists
50
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
30
0
0
0
10
10
0
11.0% a yearUS stocks since 1972
best 38%, worst -37%, max drawdown -38%, vol 17%
11.1% a yearUS real estate since 1972
best 49%, worst -38%, max drawdown -49%, vol 19%
7.9% a yearGold since 1972
best 126%, worst -32%, max drawdown -55%, vol 26%
19722024x1x2x5x10x20x50x100x200US stocksUS real estateGold

Year by year return of each strategy, every year

YearUS stocksUS real estateGold
1972+19.0%+11.0%+49.0%
1973-14.7%-16.0%+73.0%
1974-26.5%-22.0%+66.0%
1975+37.2%+37.0%-25.0%
1976+23.8%+49.0%-4.0%
1977-7.2%+22.0%+22.0%
1978+6.6%+10.0%+37.0%
1979+18.4%+35.0%+126.0%
1980+32.4%+24.0%+15.0%
1981-4.9%+6.0%-32.0%
1982+21.5%+21.0%+15.0%
1983+22.6%+30.0%-16.0%
1984+6.3%+20.0%-19.0%
1985+31.7%+19.0%+6.0%
1986+18.7%+19.0%+19.0%
1987+5.3%-10.0%+24.0%
1988+16.6%+11.0%-16.0%
1989+31.7%-2.0%-3.0%
1990-3.1%-18.0%-3.0%
1991+30.5%+35.0%-10.0%
1992+7.6%+12.0%-6.0%
1993+10.1%+19.0%+17.0%
1994+1.3%+1.0%-2.0%
1995+37.6%+18.0%+1.0%
1996+23.0%+36.0%-5.0%
1997+33.4%+21.0%-21.0%
1998+28.6%+19.0%-1.0%
1999+21.0%-17.0%+0.0%
2000-9.1%+26.0%-6.0%
2001-11.9%+14.0%+1.0%
2002-22.1%+4.0%+25.0%
2003+28.7%+38.0%+19.0%
2004+10.9%+31.0%+5.0%
2005+4.9%+12.0%+18.0%
2006+15.8%+35.0%+23.0%
2007+5.5%-18.0%+31.0%
2008-37.0%-38.0%+5.0%
2009+26.5%+28.0%+24.0%
2010+15.1%+28.0%+30.0%
2011+2.1%+8.0%+10.0%
2012+16.0%+20.0%+7.0%
2013+32.4%+3.0%-28.0%
2014+13.7%+28.0%-2.0%
2015+1.4%+3.0%-10.0%
2016+12.0%+9.0%+8.0%
2017+21.8%+5.0%+13.0%
2018-4.4%-4.0%-2.0%
2019+31.5%+29.0%+18.0%
2020+18.4%-5.0%+25.0%
2021+28.7%+40.0%-4.0%
2022-18.1%-25.0%+0.0%
2023+26.3%+12.0%+13.0%
2024+25.0%+5.0%+27.0%

Indicative, approximate annual data, sourced as well as possible. Assets covered: US stocks (S&P 500), world, international developed, emerging markets, small caps, value, growth, tech (Nasdaq), real estate (REITs), long-term bonds, 10-year and corporate bonds, high yield, commodities, gold, money market, and Bitcoin. Some series start later (emerging markets 1988, small caps 1979, high yield 1984, Bitcoin 2011). Dividends and coupons reinvested, gross returns in dollars, before tax and fees. Combinations and the custom mix are rebalanced every year. Reference sources to check: Damodaran (NYU), Ken French Data Library, SlickCharts, Visual Capitalist. Past performance does not predict the future. This is not investment advice.

Backscore rates the reliability of the evidence, not future performance. Nothing here is investment advice. All investment carries a risk of capital loss.