Educational content only. Not personalized investment advice. Historical data is indicative and should be verified before any decision. All investment carries a risk of capital loss.
Finance
Backscore: 40 trading and investment strategies scored on evidence
Backscore grades 20 trading strategies and 20 long-term investment strategies on one question: how solid is the evidence of a real edge after costs. It does not forecast returns. Below the catalogue, three tools let you practise: a market-scenario simulator, an allocation tool that projects a basket over your horizon, and a backtester on annual data from 1972 to 2024.
Free. Every lesson, article, podcast, tool and assessment, with no account needed to read.
Bet on the big future themes through specialized ETFs.
42/100
Profile
Small satellite sleeve.
Horizon
Long term, often bought at the wrong time.
Return
Very dispersed, on average below the market after launch.
In practice
On average -6% a year against the market in the first 5 years. ARKK: -80% after February 2021, ~13.8% a year since 2014 against 13.6% for the S&P 500, but three times as volatile.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
The main themes
Artificial intelligence: The hottest, high valuations.
Semiconductors: Cyclical, very volatile, the core of AI.
Clean energy: Long-term trend, sensitive to rates and subsidies.
Water: Defensive, slow and steady growth.
Robotics: Productivity and demographics.
Cybersecurity: Structurally growing spending.
Genomics: Huge but binary potential.
Aging and health: Demographic megatrend.
Defense: Driven by geopolitics.
Transition metals: Copper, lithium, grids.
Evidence2/5
Long-term robustness2/5
Low fees2/5
Controlled risk2/5
Easy to stick with3/5
In plain words: Megatrends are real.
Caveat: Specialized ETFs lose about 6% a year for 5 years after launch.
Ben-David et al., Competition for Attention in the ETF Space. See the source
How to apply it
A theme whose driver you understand.
A small satellite sleeve, never the core.
Avoid buying after the media frenzy.
A broad ETF rather than a star stock.
E
Leveraged ETFs held buy and hold
Leverage
Hold a 2x or 3x leveraged ETF over the long term.
28/100
Profile
At best, very short-term use by experienced traders.
Horizon
Designed for a single day.
Return
Drifts away from its multiple because of daily compounding.
In practice
Can end far below the underlying in a choppy market.
Historical figures, gross unless stated, never a guarantee.
Evidence2/5
Long-term robustness1/5
Low fees2/5
Controlled risk1/5
Easy to stick with2/5
In plain words: Multiplies daily gains in a steady rise.
Caveat: Volatility decay, high fees, risk of ruin.
Each strategy gets a score out of 100 and a grade from A to E. The score measures the reliability of the evidence, not the performance to come. A strategy can have made money in the past and still score low if that result does not survive costs, does not repeat out of sample or depends on a setting chosen after the fact.
A and B: solid evidenceC: average evidence, conditional on the regime or erodedD and E: weak or no evidence
The five trading criteria
Evidence
How much published research and data support the effect.
Out of sample
Whether the effect held after publication, and on markets and periods it was not designed on.
Survives costs
Whether an edge is left once fees, spreads and slippage are paid.
Robustness
Whether it works across markets and settings, or only with one tuned configuration.
Honesty
Whether the way it is usually sold matches what the data shows.
The five investment criteria
Evidence
How much research and long data series support the approach.
Long-term robustness
Whether it held over decades and across market regimes.
Low fees
What it costs to hold, year after year.
Controlled risk
How deep and how long the drops can be.
Easy to stick with
Whether an ordinary investor can keep to it through a crash without selling.
Each criterion is rated from 0 to 5. Figures quoted in the cards are historical and gross unless stated otherwise. Where a source link is missing, the reference is named and the link will be added.
Simulator
Read the market, pick your strategy, spot the trap
Choose your ground, trading or investing, and train on 29 market situations. The answer shows, with sources, the right choice and the traps.
Score 0 / 0 · streak 0 · 29 situations
E-mini S&P 5001 candle = 5 minutes20 candles
The last 20 candles swing inside a horizontal channel, with no clear direction.
RSI 250, neutral
Trend (ADX)14, very weak
Positionbetween MA50 and MA200
Volatilityaverage
Which approach fits best?
Allocation
Allocation tool: project your wealth
Enter your capital, monthly contribution, horizon and profile. The tool projects your portfolio and compares it with 100% S&P 500 and with real estate. Historical assumptions, not a guarantee.
Build your basketin percent, normalized automatically
1. Core allocationthe first decision
60%
Your stock allocation: the engine of return and of risk. Its mix is set in step 2. Historically 7 to 10% a year, with drops of 40 to 50%.
25%
Lending to governments and large companies: income and stability, a cushion for stocks. A few % a year, low volatility outside rate shocks.
10%
A real asset: rental income and capital gains, a diversifier for stocks. Total return close to stocks over the very long run, less volatile.
5%
A safe-haven metal, useful in crises and inflation. Real return close to zero, but uncorrelated in a crisis.
0%
Liquidity: safety and availability. Low return, eaten by inflation over time.
2. How to invest your stock allocation split of the Stocks share
70%
The default passive choice, the whole planet. About 7% a year, volatility 15%.
30%
The 500 largest US companies, more concentrated. About 8% a year, volatility 16%.
0%
Buy cheap stocks. Premium of about +2 to 4% a year, with long dry spells.
0%
Follow the stocks that are rising. Premium of about +3 to 5% a year, with periodic crashes.
0%
Profitable, solid companies. Premium of about +3 to 4.7% a year, more defensive.
0%
The calmest stocks. About +2 to 6% a year with less risk.
0%
Dividends that rise over time. Total return close to the market.
0%
Cheap small companies. Strong but very irregular premium.
0%
Artificial intelligence. High potential but already expensive, very volatile.
0%
The energy transition. Long-term trend, very sensitive to interest rates.
0%
The defense sector. Driven by geopolitics.
0%
Healthcare and biotechnology. Supportive demographics, wide dispersion.
0%
Water management. Defensive and durable.
0%
Cybersecurity. Spending that grows structurally.
0%
Robotics and automation. Productivity and demographics.
Basket: expected return 5.9% a year, volatility 10%. Stocks 60%, of which 0% in satellite themes.
cautiousbalancedaggressive
The range covers about two thirds of scenarios. Combining several stock factors barely diversifies, they move together; mixing stocks, bonds, gold and real estate does.
€ 100,000total paid in
€ 247,438basket, median scenario
€ 177,012 to € 353,103likely range
€ 358,710100% S&P 500
€ 252,548real estate
Each building block shows its indicative expected return and volatility. The range covers about two thirds of scenarios, at plus or minus one standard deviation, taking the basket's diversification into account. Sector themes are high risk and underperform on average once the hype fades. Approximate, historical returns, never a guarantee. This is not investment advice.
Backtester 1972-2024
Historical backtester: compare the past
Pick up to three strategies and see how a sum invested would have grown since 1972, their annualized return and their worst drawdown. Indicative annual data, to be checked.
Build my custom mix, then pick "My custom mix" in one of the three lists
50
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
30
0
0
0
10
10
0
11.0% a yearUS stocks since 1972
best 38%, worst -37%, max drawdown -38%, vol 17%
11.1% a yearUS real estate since 1972
best 49%, worst -38%, max drawdown -49%, vol 19%
7.9% a yearGold since 1972
best 126%, worst -32%, max drawdown -55%, vol 26%
Year by yearreturn of each strategy, every year
Year
US stocks
US real estate
Gold
1972
+19.0%
+11.0%
+49.0%
1973
-14.7%
-16.0%
+73.0%
1974
-26.5%
-22.0%
+66.0%
1975
+37.2%
+37.0%
-25.0%
1976
+23.8%
+49.0%
-4.0%
1977
-7.2%
+22.0%
+22.0%
1978
+6.6%
+10.0%
+37.0%
1979
+18.4%
+35.0%
+126.0%
1980
+32.4%
+24.0%
+15.0%
1981
-4.9%
+6.0%
-32.0%
1982
+21.5%
+21.0%
+15.0%
1983
+22.6%
+30.0%
-16.0%
1984
+6.3%
+20.0%
-19.0%
1985
+31.7%
+19.0%
+6.0%
1986
+18.7%
+19.0%
+19.0%
1987
+5.3%
-10.0%
+24.0%
1988
+16.6%
+11.0%
-16.0%
1989
+31.7%
-2.0%
-3.0%
1990
-3.1%
-18.0%
-3.0%
1991
+30.5%
+35.0%
-10.0%
1992
+7.6%
+12.0%
-6.0%
1993
+10.1%
+19.0%
+17.0%
1994
+1.3%
+1.0%
-2.0%
1995
+37.6%
+18.0%
+1.0%
1996
+23.0%
+36.0%
-5.0%
1997
+33.4%
+21.0%
-21.0%
1998
+28.6%
+19.0%
-1.0%
1999
+21.0%
-17.0%
+0.0%
2000
-9.1%
+26.0%
-6.0%
2001
-11.9%
+14.0%
+1.0%
2002
-22.1%
+4.0%
+25.0%
2003
+28.7%
+38.0%
+19.0%
2004
+10.9%
+31.0%
+5.0%
2005
+4.9%
+12.0%
+18.0%
2006
+15.8%
+35.0%
+23.0%
2007
+5.5%
-18.0%
+31.0%
2008
-37.0%
-38.0%
+5.0%
2009
+26.5%
+28.0%
+24.0%
2010
+15.1%
+28.0%
+30.0%
2011
+2.1%
+8.0%
+10.0%
2012
+16.0%
+20.0%
+7.0%
2013
+32.4%
+3.0%
-28.0%
2014
+13.7%
+28.0%
-2.0%
2015
+1.4%
+3.0%
-10.0%
2016
+12.0%
+9.0%
+8.0%
2017
+21.8%
+5.0%
+13.0%
2018
-4.4%
-4.0%
-2.0%
2019
+31.5%
+29.0%
+18.0%
2020
+18.4%
-5.0%
+25.0%
2021
+28.7%
+40.0%
-4.0%
2022
-18.1%
-25.0%
+0.0%
2023
+26.3%
+12.0%
+13.0%
2024
+25.0%
+5.0%
+27.0%
Indicative, approximate annual data, sourced as well as possible. Assets covered: US stocks (S&P 500), world, international developed, emerging markets, small caps, value, growth, tech (Nasdaq), real estate (REITs), long-term bonds, 10-year and corporate bonds, high yield, commodities, gold, money market, and Bitcoin. Some series start later (emerging markets 1988, small caps 1979, high yield 1984, Bitcoin 2011). Dividends and coupons reinvested, gross returns in dollars, before tax and fees. Combinations and the custom mix are rebalanced every year. Reference sources to check: Damodaran (NYU), Ken French Data Library, SlickCharts, Visual Capitalist. Past performance does not predict the future. This is not investment advice.